Davidson Institute for Talent Development
Updated 2009
Source: Davidson Institute for Talent Development
This article demystifies the "Ability-to-Benefit" rules for federal student aid as they apply to early college entrants. It also arms parents with the information they need when filling out the Free Application for Federal Student Aid. The FAFSA is required for all federal student aid, and many colleges use it for all financial aid applications.
Many early college entrants and their parents run into roadblocks when seeking federal student aid. However, families and students should not give up. Early entrance college students are eligible for federal aid as long as specific requirements are met. Because college financial aid advisors do not deal with early entrants often, they may need to be informed about specific rules that apply to these students.
WHO IS NOT QUALIFIED
- Students who are attending college courses for enrichment, but are not seeking a degree are NOT eligible for federal aid.
- Students who are enrolled in high school -- essentially any student actively seeking a high school diploma -- are NOT eligible for federal aid. This includes any students receiving high school credit for the college courses they are taking. However, this restriction does not include students who are seeking a GED. Students enrolled in both college courses and a GED program are eligible for federal aid, but federal aid money cannot be used for GED programs.
WHO IS QUALIFIED Federal student aid is offered only to "regular students," which the Department of Education defines as "one who is enrolled in an institution to obtain a degree or certificate." College students who have applied to and been accepted by a college are considered matriculated and fall under this definition.
Having a high school diploma is NOT a requirement for receiving federal aid. Students without a diploma are eligible for federal student aid if they meet other specific requirements established by the Department of Education. Unfortunately, the information regarding those exceptions is not readily available.
Although the requirements are alluded to, specific descriptions are not found on the FAFSA Web site, or in the Student Guide to federal financial aid. The Federal Student Aid Handbook, which is published by the federal government for financial aid professionals, includes detailed information about the requirements for eligibility. That document is available online at http://www.ifap.ed.gov/. The relevant section is "School-Determined Requirements" in Chapter One.
According to the handbook, there are two ways for students to establish federal financial aid eligibility without a high school diploma: 1) by establishing high school diploma equivalence or 2) under the Education Department's Ability-to-Benefit provision. Below is an outline of your options:
- DIPLOMA EQUIVALENCE
The Department of Education recognizes three equivalents for students who do not have a high school diploma or a GED.
- If a student has already completed a post-secondary program of at least two years' length, his or her transcript is acceptable, but only if the program is acceptable for full credit toward a bachelor's degree.
- Students who have completed a home study program approved by their home state can submit their certificate of completion.
- Students enrolling in a program leading to an associate degree or higher can submit documentation of academic excellence in high school and meet the requirements for admission to the college.
If a student does not meet the one of the three requirements for diploma equivalence, another option is...
- ABILITY-TO-BENEFIT
Put simply, any student who passes an Education Department-approved test or meets Education Department-approved state standards is eligible for federal financial aid under the Ability-to-Benefit provision. The Ability-to-Benefit rules (Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 34, Part 668, Subpart J www.access.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/waisidx_03/34cfr668_03.html) are independent from the admission requirements to the college or university.
Unfortunately, there is almost no crossover between the approved tests and the popular college admission tests required by most schools. This means students who are applying under the Ability-to-Benefit rules likely will have to seek out an independent testing facility that offers one of the approved tests. Such facilities may be available at some colleges and universities, but they MUST be independent from the admissions and financial aid offices at those institutions.
Approved Tests as of May 2009
| ASSET Program: Basic Skills Tests (Reading, Writing, and Numerical)--Forms B2, C2, D2 and E2
Passing Scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: Reading (35), Writing (35), and Numerical (33) |
Publisher: American College Testing (ACT) Placement Assessment Programs
2201 North Dodge Street P.O. Box 168 Iowa City, IA 52243
Contact: Dr. John D. Roth Telephone: (319) 337-1030 Fax: (319) 337-1790 Web site: www.act.org/asset/index.html |
| Career Programs Assessment (CPAT) Basic Skills Subtests (Language Usage, Reading and Numerical)--Forms B and C
Passing Scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: Language Usage (42), Reading (43), and Numerical (41) |
Publisher: American College Testing (ACT) Placement Assessment Programs
2201 North Dodge Street P.O. Box 168 Iowa City, IA 52243
Contact: Dr. John D. Roth Telephone: (319) 337-1030 Fax: (319) 337-1790 Web site: www.act.org/cpat/index.html |
| COMPASS Subtests: Prealgebra/Numerical Skills Placement, Reading Placement and Writing Placement
Passing Scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: Prealgebra/Numerical (25), Reading (62), and Writing (32) |
Publisher: American College Testing (ACT) Placement Assessment Programs
2201 North Dodge Street P.O. Box 168 Iowa City, IA 52243
Contact: Dr. John D. Roth Telephone: (319) 337-1030 Fax: (319) 337-1790 Web site: www.act.org/compass/index.html |
Combined English Language Skills Assessment (CELSA), Forms 1 and 2
Passing Scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: CELSA Form 1 (90) and CELSA Form 2 (90) |
Publisher: Association of Classroom Teacher Testers
1187 Coast Village Road, PMB 378 Montecito, CA 93108-2794
Contact: Pablo Buckelew Telephone: (805) 569-0734 Fax: (805) 569-0004 Web site: www.assessment-testing.com/celsa.htm |
| Computerized Placement Tests (CPTs) / Accuplacer (Reading Comprehension, Sentence Skills, and Arithmetic)
Passing Scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: Reading Comprehension (55), Sentence Skills (60), and Arithmetic (34) |
Publisher: The College Board
45 Columbus Avenue New York, NY 10023-6992
Contact: Ms. Suzanne Murphy Telephone: (405) 8429891 Fax: (405) 842-9894 |
Descriptive Tests: Descriptive Tests of Language Skills (DTLS) (Reading Comprehension, Sentence Structure and Conventions of Written English)--Forms MK3KDT and MK3LDT; and Descriptive Tests of Mathematical Skills (DTMS) (Arithmetic)--Forms MK3KDT and MK3LDT
Passing Scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: Reading Comprehension (108), Sentence Structure (9), Conventions of Written English (309), and Arithmetic (506)
| Publisher: The College Board
45 Columbus Avenue New York, NY 10023-6992
Contact: Ms. Suzanne Murphy Telephone: (405) 842-9891 Fax: (405) 842-9894 |
Test of Adult Basic Education (TABE): (Reading, Total Mathematics, Language)--Forms 7 and 8, Level A, Complete Battery and Survey Versions
Passing Scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: Reading (559), Total Mathematics (562), Language (545)
|
Publisher: CTB/McGraw-Hill
20 Ryan Ranch Road Monterey, CA 93940-5703.
Contact: Ms. Veronika Guerrero Telephone: (831) 393-6416 Fax: (831) 393-7128 Web site: http://www.ctb.com/ctb.com/control/productCategoryViewAction?productCategoryId=365&p=products |
| Wonderlic Basic Skills Test (WBST)--Verbal Forms VS1 & VS2, Quantitative Forms QS1 & QS2
Passing scores: The approved passing scores on this test are as follows: Verbal (200) and Quantitative (210). |
Wonderlic Personnel Test, Inc.
1795 N. Butterfield Road Libertyville, IL 60048
Contact: David Teuber Telephone: (877) 605-9499 Fax: (847) 680-9492 Web site: www.wonderlic.com/sl.9/wonderlic-basic-skills-test-wbst.aspx |
Permission Statement
|